Urgent Call for Reform: Family Demands Accountability After Son’s Tragic Death Under Mental Health Care
The family of Liam McCarlie, 35, who tragically died on April 1, 2023, while under the care of the Northamptonshire Healthcare Foundation Trust’s (NHFT) mental health team, is speaking out. His father, Doug, and stepmother, Lanor McCarlie, believe critical missed opportunities and systemic failures in patient monitoring contributed to Liam’s death, leading to a powerful call for urgent reforms in community mental health services.
The Night the System Failed: Five-Hour Ambulance Wait
The severity of the McCarlie family’s concerns was tragically highlighted during a holiday in Scotland when they received alarming messages from Liam, signaling an intent to take his own life.
«He was giving signs that he was going to kill himself. We thought ‘We can’t mess up here,'» said Mr. McCarlie. They immediately called 999 for an ambulance, despite being 600 miles (965km) away.
The ambulance took more than five hours to arrive. However, the family directs their anguish not at the ambulance service, but at the mental health team. «If only the mental health team had done a better job, we wouldn’t have needed an ambulance that night,» Mr. McCarlie stated, grappling with grief 15 months later.
A Deteriorating Condition and Missed Care Gaps
Liam’s mental health struggles began to escalate dramatically in 2021 following the death of his grandmother, whom his parents described as his «absolute rock.»
- Crisis Point: After an initial suicide attempt, Mrs. McCarlie recalled realizing «the support wasn’t there.» Despite aggressive pushing from his parents to secure a three-day crisis bed, Liam was often sent home after only one night in the hospital, falling under the care of the community mental health team.
- Waiting and Withdrawal: Liam, described by his parents as «quiet, kind, thoughtful, caring, shy and patient,» was an avid fisherman and nature photographer. He had been diagnosed with ADHD and was awaiting diagnosis for an emotionally unstable personality disorder. While waiting, he was reportedly taken off all his medication with no evidence of follow-up meetings from the mental health team.
- The Critical Downgrade: Just a week before his death, with Liam’s condition rapidly deteriorating, his family desperately sought help. Mrs. McCarlie pleaded with the community mental health team, asking, «Where can I bring him? I need to bring him now.» During a subsequent call with the Urgent Care and Assessment Team (UCAT), the urgency of his situation was allegedly downgraded, and he was given a non-urgent appointment for the following Tuesday.»We feel that was a completely missed opportunity,» Mr. McCarlie said. «It is clear he should not have been left.»
Demands for Change: Appointing Case Managers
The McCarlies had placed their faith in the NHFT system to protect their son. «We believe the system is there to protect you and help you when you need it. But that’s not our reality,» Mr. McCarlie expressed.
They are advocating for systemic changes to prevent vulnerable patients from falling through the gaps, specifically demanding:
- Dedicated Case Managers: Appointing a named case manager for every patient to «monitor» all communications with different services and escalate issues proactively.
- Family Support Programs: The establishment of maintenance programs for families and caregivers to help them support their loved ones, noting that their «emotional batteries were very low all the time.»
NHFT Response and New Initiatives
The NHFT acknowledged meeting with the coroner to address issues raised during the inquest, though no formal recommendations were issued in the report.
Adam Smith, director of mental health for the NHFT, confirmed the introduction of several new initiatives aimed at improving care:
- A new mental health crisis response center operating in conjunction with the ambulance service.
- A new mental health messaging service.
- Updated guidance emphasizing the importance of communicating with family members and carers.
- Staff training focused on the importance of completing risk assessments, creating clear safety plans, and safeguarding transitions of care.
The Trust maintains that the system of appointed case managers is already in place.
Legacy and Hope
The McCarlie family is determined to honor Liam’s memory and use his experience to foster change. They plan to turn Liam’s nature photographs—a reflection of his quiet passion—into cards to be sold, raising money for mental health charities.
If you or someone you know is struggling with mental health or having suicidal thoughts, please reach out for help immediately.
- [Insert National Crisis Hotline Number/Service Here]
- [Insert Local Emergency Number/Service Here]
You are not alone, and support is available.
#Creaton #couple #mental #health #system #son #BBC #News
